3C+Group+B





Group B- Venn Diagram above and sites and sources below [] [] Charles J. McClain, In Search of Equality: The Chinese Struggle Against Discrimination in Nineteenth-Century America (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1994)

Shih-Shan Henry Tsai, The Chinese Experience in America (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1986)

I moved sites and sources up to top. Is this where we post this? OR do we save it to something else? Kerri (about 6 inches of snow here with lots of drifting)

That works, I think we just post our final venn diagram here, so I think we are good... Christy The one that Kerri posted above seems to be a GREAT combination of all of them. I know we need to mark it as our final if we all decide that we are happy with that one... It looks really good to me. Do we want to post the top one as our final??? Kerri - I'm sorry about your 2-year old - hope you are all doing better. The groups were listed in one of the facilitator forum posts. I think we keep our same groups, I looked ahead and there is another group assignment in the first part of module 4... Shelly- I don't know how Harrisburg looks, but in southern Lancaster county we have over 2 feet of snow! - Christy

1 and 5 work for me as well... I put larger copies of those 2 on here. I also did a real quick compare / contrast on the attached venn diagram. I have to be honest, I am NOT the best at seeing the symbolism in political cartoons (maybe I am terrible...), so I am glad that this is a group effort!! :-)



Christy

1. Welcome to All

2. As to Japanese Exclusion

3. Where both playforms agree (I think it should say "platforms", but it says "playforms"??)

4. Ching Cartoon

5. Hoodwinked



Hi everyone: I will do some research on both 1 and 5, as I typically deal with science, and am not very good with political satire. I will get back to you later on today, probably before you are out of school, as I am home sick today. Sorry it took so long to check in, but I was out of town for two days. Thanks, Shelly

.



Hey guys, I looked at your diagrams and tried to add on, however after going back it looks as if our group had our own venn diagram! You guys have done a great job of researching the topic! After doing this though, I can tell why I am a PE teacher! Great job to all! -Brett

See what you think!!

Shelly, WOW, you really did a lot of research on those cartoons. I went with what I saw in my analysis. I guess when we see what Brett and Kerri have to say, we can put it all together. - Christy

I think both diagrams are great. I can tell this assignment is not going to be my forte. Like Christy, I'm not the best at seeing the symbolism in the cartoons. I think the first diagram analyzes more from the surface, just by looking at it. And the second goes deeper into the meaning of it. A combination of both would be good. Did I miss a message or anything where the instructor gave us our groups? I feel like I've missed something. Sorry it took me so long to get on. My two year old broke her collar bone Tuesday and we were in hospital all day Wednesday with her. I'll be on a lot this weekend. Kerri

My backup information regarding Hoodwinked. (Shelly) []

Exclusion of Chinese laborers into the U.S. because they endanger the good of order of certain territories.

[] China herself prevented emigration to the United States unless monetary assets or family were already in place. U.S. did not want any visiting Chinese back to China, readmitted to the U.S.

The Bayard-Zhang Treaty prohibited Chinese immigration or the return of Chinese laborers to the U.S. for twenty years, unless the laborers had assets worth at least $1,000 or immediate family living in America. The United States government agreed to protect Chinese people and property in America.

Source:
 * Charles J. McClain, In Search of Equality: The Chinese Struggle Against Discrimination in Nineteenth-Century America (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1994) ||  ||
 * Shih-Shan Henry Tsai, The Chinese Experience in America (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1986) ||  ||
 * Shih-Shan Henry Tsai, The Chinese Experience in America (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1986) ||  ||

I hope some of this helps, I will be out of town again tonight, going to Harrisburg, PA for the second time this week. Shelly I copied and pasted all diagrams to make one, but am having trouble posting it on here. I thought all of us would be able to edit one diagram, but I couldn't pull up the documents under the edit now mode. Kerri I got it inserted at top of page kerri